data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63f56/63f564bbe38008017446ac71b2c80c40a594ecde" alt="Logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art"
Edwin Ortiz of HipHopDX found Logic's fourth effort (not including Psychological) as an indication of his vision, saying, "In a little over three years, Logic has gone from a young lyricist with raw potential to a legitimate rap artist with Welcome to Forever." Multiple sources state that Logic's cohesive lyricism has never been a point of question. DJBooth agreed with HipHopDX in saying Young Sinatra: Welcome to Forever had top notch production and sounded like an album. HipHopDX's consensus determined the project as a "free album," their highest possible praise for a mixtape on the site. Young Sinatra: Welcome to Forever received critical acclaim from critics. Producers who contributed to the mixtape included Logic himself, 6ix, Arthur McArthur, C-Sick, Don Cannon, Kevin Randolph, Key Wane, and No I.D. Welcome to Forever features guest appearances from Kid Ink (from his 2013 XXL Freshman class), Trinidad James and Dizzy Wright along with Jhené Aiko, Elijiah Blake, C Dot Castro, and Jon Bellion. So if there are features you want them to make sense and have them as something that people are going to be excited for whether they're unexpected or not".
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ef691/ef6917d4edc65d3c5921e87d22470962530f787b" alt="logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art"
I don’t mean that to sound arrogant but when you listen to someone's music it's them you want to hear not a million and one other people. "I love to give the people what they want and that's me. In an interview with MTV Hive about his features, Logic replied:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d3772/d3772e1699fc27d78c4bf33dc0229e49e205b697" alt="logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e3af6/e3af6895cb2b37f7808fe00aa56cd562797eab03" alt="logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art"
In the time leading up to the release of Young Sinatra: Welcome to Forever, Logic released the music videos for "Walk On By" and "Nasty".
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63f56/63f564bbe38008017446ac71b2c80c40a594ecde" alt="Logic young sinatra welcome to te futire cover art"